When Alice and Bob bank at the same institution, paying Bob is trivial: one ledger, two entries, done. But most payments cross between banks — and now two independent ledgers have to end up consistent without either bank simply trusting the other. A payment is therefore not a single instant; it is a sequence.
The stages of a payment
Follow $100 from Alice (at Bank A) to Bob (at Bank B):
- Instruction — Alice tells Bank A to pay Bob. Bank A debits Alice.
- Clearing — Bank A passes the payment through a shared clearing system that routes it to Bank B and records that Bank A now owes Bank B $100.
- Credit — Bank B credits Bob. Bob can see and often spend the money.
- Settlement — Bank A actually transfers $100 to Bank B, usually in central-bank reserves. Only now is the payment truly final and irreversible.
Step through it in the widget below and watch the balances — and the interbank obligation — change at each stage.
Credited is not settled
The subtle, important point lives between steps 3 and 4. Bob has his money before the banks have settled between themselves. In that window, Bank A still owes Bank B. If Bank A failed at that exact moment, Bank B could be left out of pocket having already paid Bob. That exposure is settlement risk, and managing it is a central concern of every payment system — the reason banks hold reserves, post collateral, and set limits on each other.
Why there are so many "rails"
Different payment rails make different trade-offs on exactly this timing:
- Real-time gross settlement (RTGS) settles each payment individually and immediately in central-bank money — no settlement risk, but it consumes a lot of reserves and is reserved for large or urgent payments.
- Deferred net settlement (most retail rails, card networks, ACH) lets payments accumulate and settles only the net amounts later — cheap and efficient, but it carries risk during the delay.
- Instant payment schemes push retail payments toward real-time credit while managing the settlement risk behind the scenes.
Cards, bank transfers, ACH, RTGS, instant rails — they differ mostly in this speed-versus-risk-versus-cost balance. The netting that makes deferred settlement so efficient deserves its own look: clearing and settlement, next.